Uhh, this will make zero sense if you have not seen the show. And probably 75% sense if you have.
I’m behind–I’ve only seen the first two episodes. I’ve not read the books, I doubt I will, and I don’t care if/how a reading of them could enrich my viewing experience. On one hand, the series is a compelling soap opera in that epic way–betrayals, political struggles, brutal people who adhere more to a way of life that resembles what I think of when I think of 16th century Europe.
On the other hand, it has this sleazy-sexy thing going on, and that’s not really my speed nowadays. I feel like I want 100% sleazy (“HELLO, MY NAME IS _PORN_”) or just dramz. Smooching ok, sexy ok too. Example: Game of Thrones brings you a political bride being raped and crying on her wedding night (probably a virgin, which does not make the rape “worse” but you can imagine that her terror and pain has a slightly different dimension than an experienced woman’s would). Sex is happening, but it’s sleazy. (I don’t feel like writing about rape fantasies and the validity thereof or the invaildity, but there, I have stuck my finger in the frosting of the rape fantasy cake. I SEE IT.)
Technically it passes the Bechdel Test, which of course does not make something FEMINIST or NOT, or GOOD or BAD, it just passes it. I’ll tell you what I remember in a minute and what my problem is with the conversation that made it pass. So, GoT is not 100% sausage party with ladies oohing and ahhing over awesomeness and the potential acquisition of said sausages.
Idly curious, I decided to have a quick look to see if people were discussing GoT in the context of the Bechdel Test and this is what I found. The timing is such that it seems to have been posted after the first episode. Granted, there is absolutely no commentary or discussion here to even get the tiniest pickax into, but I feel like the tone is “GAME OF THRONES GOTS LADIES INNIT.” Yeah, it does. Big whoop.
In the second episode, there is a real moment of two women talking, and not about dreamy princes or being cheated on by out of control rapscalliony husbands and also not just a giggling pile of whores. The bad lady is talking to the grumpy lady (yes I am going Honey Badger on this “review” with names and crap), who is waiting for her extremely concussed son to wake up, and the bad lady shares that she lost a child. It would be like a thing that two women who understand the pain of being mothers might discuss privately, but the Bad Lady is the reason the little boy is in the light coma. I got the sense she was just covering her ass should the child wake up, or perhaps it was just to show the audience that she is completely sociopathic (let me share your sadness after I pushed your kid out of a tower).
So, I get it, plot developments and any lady conversations are going to be in service of the intriguey politics. Again, nothing inherently wrong with this, it’s just not a show that is concerned about the formation/development of healthy female relationships, whereas I do feel like there is a lot of man-to-man, fully-clothed, not-talking-about “OOOH I DEW HOPE I CAN MARRY A DUCHESS” bonding moments. It’s a man’s world in the Game of Thrones. Could there be a fantasy historical-style epic that involved women being treated not as chattel, baby vessels, or long suffering wives, because Them’s How Things Were In The Olden Days? (There has to be a name for fantasies that appeal precisely because they are “allowed” to take place in a pre-feminist era.) Do I want to continue? Probably not.
Other Minor Quibbles:
* Titties titties LOADS of TITTAYS. Flapping up, flapping down, here’s some whores, here’s some more. Here’s some whores painted blue. Here’s someone’s brother pulling out her titties. Great. No manparts and not even total man butt, I don’t think. This is telling me that the show is not really for me, per se, because mix it up, for fuck’s sake, or just focus on the plot. Yes, I know who you are, HBO, and that you’re kind of a “big deal” around here. Whatever.
* More sleazy-sexy: incest plot. Yes, a guy fucking his sister is showing, not telling, A++ story writers. Again, though, I don’t think we’re going to be seeing a healthy sexual relationship anytime soon.
*HEY, blonde sad bride has a handmaiden who speaks her language, neat! Handmaiden was a baby whore. Well, ok. Oh! Then the interaction between these two women becomes strictly homoerotic as the ex-whore shows the new bride how to hump her husband entertainingly. I see now. Why does sad bride want to learn how to please this oafy gorilla, who seems pretty content with 30 seconds of doggystyle? Is she afraid he’s going to get tired of her and gut her and leave her in the desert? That’s fair. Is it because all bitches are secretly cock-gobbling maniacs inside, just waiting to be unleashed? Just tell us what her motivation is, please. I was hoping that she would have a relationship with her handmaiden, not because it would be titillating (which it would, COUGH) but because they actually seem to like each other.
*Stop punishing the spunky girl for being awesome.
If I quit this, I will say I will miss yelling “PUPPIES” at the screen whenever the pet Dire Wolves show up, especially as they are now grown and mauling people.